E-ink case, printed photo case or clear case with a photo: which should you choose?
Remember sliding a photo behind a clear case? This is what that idea looks like when the picture can change.
The short answer
A printed photo case shows one picture for good. A clear case shows whatever photo you slide behind it, one at a time. An e-ink case shows any picture you send from your phone and changes whenever you like, with nothing printed to peel. Printed and clear cases cost less and show full colour.
E-ink vs printed vs clear: how do the 3 compare?
The 3 kinds of photo case differ most in how you change the picture and what a new look costs.
| E-ink case (Morph's Canvas Case) | Printed photo case | Photo behind a clear case | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Changing the picture | From the app, in seconds | Buy another case | Swap the photo by hand |
| Pictures per case | As many as you like | One, for good | One at a time |
| After a year | Sits under a protective layer. Nothing to peel or yellow | Print can scratch or lift at a corner | Clear plastic yellows and the photo curls |
| Charging | No battery. Wireless charging works through it | Nothing to charge | Nothing to charge |
| Colour | Softer, like ink on paper | Full colour | Full colour |
| Cost of a new look | Nothing | A new case each time | A new print each time |
| Price to buy | $69 to $109, the highest of the 3 | Lower | Lowest |
When is a printed photo case the right choice?
A printed photo case is the right choice when you have one picture you'll never tire of and you want it in full colour for a low price. A printed case does that well.
The trade is that the picture is permanent while the print isn't. It can scratch or lift at a corner with wear, and a new picture means a new case.
When is a clear case with a photo the right choice?
A clear case with a photo is the right choice when you like the ritual: print a photo, trim it, slide it in. It's cheap and it's yours.
The catches are the ones everyone who's done it remembers: the photo curls, clear plastic yellows, and changing it means printing again. The yellowing is in the plastic. Flexible clear cases are often made of thermoplastic polyurethane, and Wikipedia's entry on the material notes that a different formula is used when "stable light colour and non-yellowing performance are required".
When is an e-ink case the right choice?
An e-ink case is the right choice when you change, and most of us do. A case usually stays on a phone for a year or two, and in that time the person carrying it has birthdays, a new job and a few hard months. An e-ink case keeps up: your kids this week, a holiday the next.
The picture is drawn by the panel, under a protective layer, so there's nothing to peel and nothing to reprint.
“Never get bored of my phone case anymore.”
What are the trade-offs of an e-ink case?
An e-ink case has 3 trade-offs, and they're real.
- Colour. E-ink is softer than a print and never glows. Some colours come through stronger than others, and the app shows you the result before you send it.
- Speed. A change takes seconds while the panel redraws, around 20 on a Canvas Pro. It's quick, but you'll watch it happen.
- Price. A Morph e-ink case costs $69 to $109, more than a printed or clear case. After that, a new look costs nothing.
Is an e-ink case just a print behind plastic?
No. There's no print in an e-ink case. The picture is drawn by an electronic paper display built into the case, which is why it can change, and why it stays with no battery once it's drawn. What is an e-ink phone case? explains how.
Quick questions
- Is an e-ink phone case worth it?
- It's worth it if you'd otherwise change cases or photos a few times a year, or if you want your own pictures on your phone without committing to one. If you want one picture for good at the lowest price, a printed case will do.
- Do printed phone cases peel?
- They can. Print sits on the surface, so it can scratch or lift at a corner with wear.
- Why do clear phone cases turn yellow?
- Clear plastic yellows with age and use. A photo behind it can curl as well.
- Can an e-ink case show more than one photo?
- One at a time, and as many as you like over time. You send a new one from the app whenever you want a change.
Sources
- Thermoplastic polyurethane, Wikipedia. The quote on non-yellowing plastic. The entry lists mobile phone covers among the material's uses.
- Customer review by Hasan S., shown with the other customer reviews on themorph.com.au.
- Morph's prices: Morph's own price list.